⏱ 2 min read
The Short Version
Forget obsessing over calcium and magnesium; bicarbonate is the real flavor killer. While hardness barely touches the cup, high alkalinity aggressively buffers acidity and fruitiness, turning bright, premium brews into flat, bitter messes.
Baristas often obsess over magnesium and calcium levels, treating water hardness like wine terroir. However, new research from a University of Copenhagen team suggests we may be seasoning the wrong ingredient altogether. Published in the Journal of Food Science, the study reveals that while hardness might play a role in equipment maintenance, alkalinity fundamentally dictates flavor profiles.
Coffee brewed with 264 mg/L of calcium was statistically indistinguishable from the ultrapure reference on every attribute.
The myth of mineral importance
The researchers conducted sensory panels using Colombian Kachalu coffee brewed with ultrapure water treated with varying levels of calcium, magnesium, and bicarbonate. They tested these minerals both within and far beyond the Specialty Coffee Association’s recommended zones. Coffee brewed with 264 mg/L of calcium was statistically indistinguishable from the ultrapure reference on every attribute. Magnesium followed suit; despite its reputation for enhancing extraction, it failed to leave a meaningful mark on the cup.
Bicarbonate, however, acted as a decisive variable. At concentrations of 300 mg/L, tasters reported a massive drop in perceived acidity—falling from 12.0 to 2.9 on a 15 cm scale—and fruitiness plummeted from 10.2 to 2.4. As bicarbonate buffered the acids baristas prize, bitter and roasted notes climbed, and the average brew pH rose from 4.88 to 5.53. Even at 120 mg/L, the impact of bicarbonate was detectable by trained panelists.
Prioritizing alkalinity in brewing
This shift suggests that current water programs may be overcomplicating hardness while ignoring the buffering capacity of the water. Brewers must also account for chemical instability: when high calcium is paired with high bicarbonate, the intended chemistry can fail because calcium carbonate precipitates before brewing. The water quietly changes itself, meaning simply adding minerals isn’t enough if they aren’t staying in solution.
While the study focused on a single medium-roast coffee and did not measure extraction yield, the implications for specialty coffee are clear. Light roasts may react differently, but the data provides a practical starting point: prioritize measuring alkalinity above all else. To protect the complexity and bright acidity that define premium beans, brewers should keep bicarbonate levels modest. If you are investing in new mineral kits or filtration systems, the most important question to ask is what they do to your bicarbonate levels.
Do you adjust your water chemistry based on hardness or alkalinity?
Questions & Answers
How does bicarbonate affect the flavor of brewed coffee?
Bicarbonate levels fundamentally dictate flavor profiles by buffering the acids that define coffee taste. High concentrations of bicarbonate cause a significant drop in perceived acidity and fruitiness while increasing bitter and roasted notes. In one study, increasing bicarbonate to 300 mg/L caused acidity scores to plummet from 12.0 to 2.9 on a 15 cm scale. This buffering effect raises the average brew pH, which can strip away the bright, complex characteristics that specialty coffee drinkers typically prize in premium beans.
What is the difference between water hardness and alkalinity in coffee brewing?
Water hardness refers to the concentration of minerals like calcium and magnesium, whereas alkalinity refers to the water's buffering capacity, often driven by bicarbonate. While baristas often focus on hardness for extraction or equipment maintenance, research suggests alkalinity has a much larger impact on flavor. Calcium and magnesium levels can sometimes be adjusted without significantly altering the sensory attributes of the coffee. In contrast, changes in bicarbonate levels can drastically transform the acidity and fruitiness of the final cup.
Why can high calcium and bicarbonate levels cause issues in brewing water?
High levels of calcium paired with high bicarbonate can cause chemical instability through the precipitation of calcium carbonate. When these two elements are present in high concentrations, the intended water chemistry can fail because the minerals precipitate before the brewing process even begins. This means the water effectively changes its own composition, making it difficult for brewers to maintain consistent results. Simply adding minerals to a water program is often insufficient if those minerals do not remain properly in solution.
Which water minerals have the most significant impact on coffee acidity?
Bicarbonate has a much more decisive impact on coffee acidity than minerals like calcium or magnesium. While magnesium is often thought to enhance extraction, studies show it may fail to leave a meaningful mark on the sensory attributes of the cup. Calcium levels can also be quite high without being statistically distinguishable from ultrapure water. However, even modest amounts of bicarbonate can noticeably buffer acids, making it the most critical variable for brewers to monitor when they want to protect bright acidity.
Originally reported by Barista Magazine.

