JDE Peet’s Shift Triggers Drop in Sustainable Coffee Volume

Macro close-up of textured green unroasted coffee beans in a pile.

⏱ 2 min read

The Short Version

Sustainable coffee volumes just took their first major hit, plummeting as industry giants like JDE Peet’s pivot from traditional certifications to internal risk-based models. This strategic shift proves that aggregate data often masks reality: a drop in "certified" beans doesn't necessarily mean a drop in responsibility.

After years of steady growth, sustainable coffee purchasing has seen its first significant decline. According to the Global Coffee Platform (GCP) 2025 Sustainable Coffee Purchases Report, approximately 69% of green coffee purchased by 14 major roasters met recognized sustainability standards this year—a notable drop from the 75% recorded in 2024. While more companies joined the reporting initiative this year, including Lidl, NewCoffee, and Ringtons, the overall volume of certified coffee fell by nearly 9%.

These findings underline both the value and the limits of current collective reporting.

The impact of sourcing shifts

This downward trend was largely driven by a strategic pivot from one industry heavyweight. JDE Peet’s saw its purchases meeting GCP-recognized standards plummet from 72.94% in 2024 to just 47.04% in 2025. However, the company maintains that its sourcing is still responsible; it has moved away from traditional certification-based models toward a human rights and environmental due diligence (HREDD) risk-based approach. Under this new framework, JDE Peet’s reported that 88.8% of its 2025 green coffee was responsibly sourced. These findings underline both the value and the limits of current collective reporting. Because large buyers are changing how they define and track “sustainable” beans, the aggregate data can mask individual progress or regression.

The decline was fueled primarily by a contraction in “2nd Party Assurance Systems,” which encompass in-house verification programs and tailored schemes like Enveritas. Volumes in this category dropped 26%, even as third-party certifications such as Fairtrade, Rainforest Alliance, and 4C remained relatively stable. This shift highlights how much the overall percentage is tied to these specific types of customized assurance programs rather than a total loss of sustainability efforts.

Moving beyond volume metrics

Despite the statistical dip, the report highlights a deeper systemic issue: purchasing volume alone does not guarantee better lives for producers. The 2026 Coffee Barometer recently showed that average farming households in eight of the world’s ten largest producing countries still fail to meet living-income benchmarks. As Brazil and Vietnam continue to dominate the sustainable volume—accounting for roughly 61% of reported coffee—the geographic diversity of these purchases has actually narrowed.

GCP Executive Director Annette Pensel argues that the industry must move toward new ways of measurement to understand actual impact on the ground. To combat persistent poverty, GCP is now collaborating with IDH, Solidaridad, and GIZ to develop shared procurement principles that prioritize long-term relationships and shared risk over simple certification checkboxes.

Does a shift from third-party certification to internal due diligence make coffee sourcing more or less transparent?

Questions & Answers

Why did the percentage of sustainable coffee purchases decline in 2025?

The decline was primarily driven by a strategic shift in sourcing methods by JDE Peet’s. While the overall percentage of green coffee meeting recognized sustainability standards dropped from 75% to 69%, this was largely due to the company moving away from traditional certification-based models. JDE Peet’s transitioned to a human rights and environmental due diligence approach, which changed how its purchases are categorized in aggregate reports despite the company maintaining high levels of responsible sourcing.

How is JDE Peet’s changing its approach to sustainable coffee sourcing?

JDE Peet’s is moving away from traditional certification-based models in favor of a human rights and environmental due diligence (HREDD) risk-based approach. Under this new framework, the company reported that 88.8% of its 2025 green coffee was responsibly sourced. This strategic pivot explains why the company's reported compliance with recognized GCP standards fell significantly, even though the company maintains that its internal sourcing practices remain responsible and focused on environmental and human rights risks.

What caused the drop in second-party assurance systems within the coffee industry?

The contraction in second-party assurance systems was caused by a significant shift in how large buyers verify their coffee supply chains. Volumes in this category, which include in-house verification programs and tailored schemes like Enveritas, dropped by 26%. This trend occurred even as third-party certifications like Fairtrade and Rainforest Alliance remained stable. The decline reflects a broader industry movement where companies are opting for customized assurance programs rather than relying solely on traditional, external certification checkboxes.

How do coffee sustainability metrics relate to the living income of farmers?

Purchasing volume metrics often fail to reflect the actual economic impact on coffee producers living in major producing countries. While sustainable coffee volumes are tracked, the 2026 Coffee Barometer indicates that average farming households in eight of the world's ten largest producing countries still fail to meet living-income benchmarks. Because of this gap, organizations like the Global Coffee Platform are working to develop new procurement principles that prioritize long-term relationships and shared risk over simple volume-based certification metrics.


Originally reported by Daily Coffee News.

By ADMIN@CoffeeWineTea.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like