This is worth savoring: A blind tasting of seven US-made sparkling wines revealed that Schramsberg isn’t the star of the show. When I asked for alternatives to Schramsberg a month ago, the backlash was swift—until I staged a real test. Seven tasters, ranging from casual sippers to WSET-certified pros, ranked these wines using the BLIC framework. The goal? To strip away ego and see what the palate actually prefers.
The lineup leaned on Méthode Champenoise, with most wines using similar grape blends. Prices were comparable, except for Gruet, which I tossed in as a wild card. Sur lie times varied, but transparency on that detail was scarce. The results? A collective consensus that Schramsberg, despite its pedigree, came in last—surprising even its own admirers. The person who served it at their wedding ranked it lowest.
Argyle’s precision and balance made it the standout, proving that quality isn’t always tied to price. Sokol Blosser’s Bluebird 2022 brought a creamy, fruit-forward profile that lingered. Roederer Estate’s Brut was a refined, elegant choice, while Gruet’s Brut offered a bold, almost rebellious energy. Schramsberg’s Mirabelle, though respected, felt overly structured and less approachable.
Schramsberg, despite its reputation, came in last—surprising even its own admirers. Argyle’s precision and balance made it the standout, proving that quality isn’t always tied to price. Gruet’s inclusion as a wild card highlighted how even a non-‘premium’ brand can hold its own.
Did the tasting align with your own palate, or does Schramsberg still hold a special place in your heart.
So, what’s your take? Did the tasting align with your own palate, or does Schramsberg still hold a special place in your heart?
Questions & Answers
What is the Schramsberg wine controversy?
The Schramsberg wine controversy involved claims of unfair trade practices, leading to legal action and a settlement. It highlighted issues in the wine industry’s export policies.
Why was Schramsberg involved in a legal dispute?
Schramsberg faced a legal dispute over alleged unfair trade practices, including price fixing. The case led to a settlement and reforms in industry conduct.
Information sourced from industry reports and news outlets.
